Frank Cikutovich Article:
Human Rights Proposals Face More Study by City Council
Spokesman Review Mar 20, 1998 by Virginia de Leon Staff writer
It'll be at least a month before the City Council votes on two proposed human
rights ordinances - one that would ban discrimination in Spokane and another
that would allow long-term committed couples to register as domestic
partners.
Council members want more information about the costs of implementing such
laws, they said Thursday during a meeting with Spokane's Human Rights
Commission.
The council appointed City Attorney Jim Sloane to study Seattle's
anti-discrimination law and a domestic partnership registry approved in 1994. A
number of cities, including Eugene, Ore.; Madison, Wis.; and Minneapolis have
similar laws. "These ordinances can go a long way in improving the image of this
city," said commission member Keith Wolter. "Ensuring human rights is not only
the right thing to do, but it's good for business." It shows that Spokane is "a
friendly and welcoming city," he said. Although public testimony wasn't allowed,
more than 30 people showed up to hear the discussion between the commission and
City Council. The proposed ordinances have caused some controversy because they
include protection of people based on sexual orientation and gender identity -
rights not guaranteed in state and federal laws. The proposed laws also would
prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, religion, color, sex, national
origin, marital status, disability, age and familial status. The ordinances have
been in the works since last summer. After meeting with concerned citizens,
former Mayor Jack Geraghty assigned the 13-member Human Rights Commission to
develop an anti-discrimination plan. It wouldn't cost much to enforce the laws,
said Frank Cikutovich, an attorney and commission member. In fact, the domestic
partnership registry would create revenue. If the City Council approves the
ordinance, both gay and heterosexual couples could pay $25 to register at the
city clerk's office. It also may cost couples money to remove their names from
the registry. But the cost of enforcing the anti-discrimination law still is
unknown. That's why the council wants more time to study Seattle's law. The
Human Rights Commission still will work with people who file discrimination
complaints, but the law would allow people to bring their complaints to the city
hearing examiner if mediation doesn't work. Hearing Examiner Greg Smith told the
council he isn't sure of the law's fiscal impact, especially since civil rights
law is not his expertise. He may need some training, he said. "Costs shouldn't
be part of human rights," Councilman Jeff Colliton said, adding that he wants to
study existing anti-discrimination laws before making a decision. The council
plans to have another work session with the commission when more information
about costs is available.
Copyright 1998 Cowles Publishing Company Provided by
Stiley and Cikutovich, PLLC.
1408 W. Broadway Spokane, Wa. ,
99201 Office Phone: (509) 323-9000 Fax: (509)
324-9029 www.legaljoint.net
|